In this post, I'm reacting to Iverson's admission that social networks like his own JuicyCampus needed to be reigned in after the type of responses given by anonymous perusers got out of control. His intent appeared to be different than the outcome, but to name it JuicyCampus with the ad slogan "C'mon give us the juice", just what else could he expect? People were able to hide behind their anonymity and posted whatever gossip came to mind, whether is was partial truth or an outright lie. Who'd know? He reflected upon several examples where people's private lives became instantly public, resulting in dire consequences. He says he had to trash the site, resulting in it being added to "The DeadPool."
Connecting this to Thirteen Reasons Why by Jay Asher makes me think, as an educator, just how liable I am when I allow students to participate in a blog. Luckily, I am overcautious, probably to a fault, and I have every post go through my school email. Creating a digital paper-trail, if you will, allows for credibility for me and my students. When I showed students an example of how to add to the blog, they were astonished that they had to provide a name and email. Of course,with technology, there's a way to misrepresent yourself. Students could put a fake name or could provide a fake email, but because posts would go through me ultimately, I feel pretty secure that nothing inappropriate would get publicly posted. I've had students email me in the past, and anything strange gets sent to the vice-principal for further investigation.
I couldn't help but feel a twinge of sympathy for Mr. Porter in Thirteen Reasons Why. He was her English teacher moonlighting as a guidance counselor, but overall, I was astonished at his ineptness. The conversation they had (#13) showed that he was trying to help, but just didn't have the support available to meet her needs. It makes me think of our teachers or behavior managers trying to moonlight, or give advice, as though they are trained psychologists. Students will share information, sometimes very personal, with the school adults in their lives. It's crucial, however, to recognize what kind of support you can give at your level of expertise. Common core standards do not address this 'other hat' aspect of a teachers' many roles. Instead, outside groups such as family services have a yearly inservice about mandated reporting. I know that the support staff (guidance, student center, and school psychologists) diligently work to address the many needs of students.
I can incorporate this moral lesson into my teaching involves using the examples from Iverson and having students research online to find out "where they are now." Because my students are egocentric, I would want them to collaborate with upperclassmen. The best time to do this activity would be during intervention, when the upperclassmen are available. I would also have the anti-bullying task force and my connections group participate in creating scenarios that the students respond to online. I would be able to have them respond on their student weebly blogs. This type of communication would be beneficial because the source is their peer group. The following standards reflect the ideas of this lesson.
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.SL.9-10.5 Make strategic use of digital media (e.g., textual, graphical, audio, visual, and interactive elements) in presentations to enhance understanding of findings, reasoning, and evidence and to add interest
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.SL.9-10.1d Respond thoughtfully to diverse perspectives, summarize points of agreement and disagreement, and, when warranted, qualify or justify their own views and understanding and make new connections in light of the evidence and reasoning presented
Ivester & Asher: post#4 revised again
3:58 PM |
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
You’re post really meant a lot to me; as did also reading this novel. I have had times at school where I’ve worried about wearing too many hats at school that I am not fully trained to be wearing. My school does not have a guidance counselor or a social worker. I am often left answering tough questions and dealing with issues that I know I am not qualified for. I often protect myself by just listening to the child. I then ask for another teacher, nurse, or principal, to help me offer advice with the child. I rarely offer any advice that is personal without first talking to someone else. I always fill in the nurse and principals in with anything that I feel I need an ally for. Luckily, most of the stories my third graders report haven’t been too horrific. My school did a great job of reminding me when I was hired that I am a mandated reported, but to never feel that I am alone when having to deal with such issues. Being in a small school and not having many qualified people we all come together with what we do know and work as a team, which really makes me feel better. If I was Mr. Potter I would have found the resources to help, even if I didn’t think I could personally be of help. I think it is common for teachers to want to help, its part of what makes us want to teach. You can’t be the type of person who wants to fix everything yourself when it comes to children, it is truly a team effort!
Alicia,
I had the same reaction to Ivester setting up Juicy Campus, he makes it seem so well intentioned but I agree, what did he expect to happen with this site? I feel that as educators we clearly are in the people business, but it is often easy to get bogged down with lesson planning and the ins and outs of prep work and not always remember everything our students have going on in their lives. I think that since technology opens new lines of communication this can hopefully work to help students who may avoid seeking help in person but may so online.
What a cautionary tale! I also think Iverson's experience with JuicyCampus should have been expected. In the digital world, just like the analog world, there are all types of people and not all of them share a common decency and morality required for a civilized society. Things quickly spiral out of control when posters can remain anonymous. If a poster is identified, he or she can be held accountable.
Alicia, you make a very good point about knowing your level of capability when it comes to counseling a troubled student. I have little training in this area but know when it's the right time to refer a student to our qualified support team at my school.
Post a Comment